Last night on 60 Minutes Lesley Stahl went to see the Frozen Zoo, the Audubon Nature Institute's Species Survival Center. The center is doing fascinating. historic, ground-breaking work storing the DNA of threatened species and even producing clones of endangered African wildcats. What was missing from the story, however, was a closer look at the context in which the center operates. If Stahl and 60 Minutes had asked the following questions, the piece might not have been as much of an inane exercise.
Who's paying for all this?
The nonprofit Audubon Nature Institute grew out of a once ailing, old New Orleans institution. They're not related to the Audubon Club. ANI runs a zoo, insectarium and Imax theatre. So are they supporting the whole $43 million operation (including the $2.5 million it costs to save endangered species) by creeping out kids with bugs and selling zoo T-shirts? If so, that would be quite a feat and worth knowing. Too bad Stahl didn't ask.
The issue is important because in 2007 the Washington Post's Philip Kennicott pointed out ANI's ties to big oil, raising the possibility it used Chevron money to make a lame Katrina Imax movie that doesn't mention oil's role in destroying wetlands. (No way, say the film-maker and Audubon: Chevron was just ordered by a court to funnel cash to an environmental cause and they chose this one.)
According to finances posted online, the operation just about breaks even (a loss of $187,000 in 2008, the latest year available). Unless you count capital expenses. Which the center curiously doesn't. And they're huge: $41 million, most of which went to insectarium. The center is supported by its own foundation, which was worth $30 million in 2007, according to Guidestar. It got some federal money from helping save the whooping crane and a little bug money Terminix. And it pays longtime New Orleans politician Ron Forman about $500,000 a year (as of their latest filings)--though that's down from the $700,000 he got in 2000.
Frankly, the work is so important I might not mind if the center raised money by selling zoo T-shirt to strippers who entice people to gamble, smoke and drink candy-flavored liquor. But I'd want to know.
What about the Thylacine? Who cares about Wooly Mammoths? When are you going to bring us a a Thylacine?
The Thylacine is the emblem of a species that was allowed to go extinct in modern times. So why are we talking about the wooly mammoth?
The Thylacine, also known as the Tasmanian Tiger, was an Australian striped marsupial went extinct so recently (1933) there's video of it on YouTube. Some Australians debate whether some might still exist on Tasmania. Meanwhile, the Australian Museum has been working on bringing it back from extinction for years using the same idea Audubon is talking about: taking DNA from museum specimens. So why aren't these two working together?
Is this part of some international movement to make a library of animal DNA?
Because the Animal Gene Storage Resource Center of Australia seems to be doing the same exact thing. And Advanced Cell Technology also bred an endangered Javan Bentang in a cow. None of that takes away from the great stuff ANI is doing, but I'd like to hear where they fit in.
Why skin cells?
Why is ANI concentrating on skins cells instead of blood or gametes? Is skin better? Or are they really gearing up for using skin from old museum cells?
Why don't those guys burying seeds in the arctic give you some storage space?
The Global Crop Diversity Trust runs an arctic bunker for seeds, which 60 Minutes covered in 2008. And it's way better funded and advanced with a bunker set to survive disaster. Wouldn't that be a safer place to put endnagered DNA than New Orleans? Aren't animals more important?
Instead we get these questions:
So it's really more like an ark than a zoo?
Stahl points out. Brilliant observation. Like it was in the BBC's 2005 headline on the place. Those canisters of liquid nitrogen wouldn't be much fun to look.
After bringing up the way distant possibility of rewriting DNA to meet our criteria, Stahl then asks, with great surprise, if they could possibly CLONE the extinct or endangered species.
Ok, cloning is like photo-copying. It already exists. It's no longer science fiction. It's here. So why be shocked? And why throw in this idea of editing DNA, which still is science fiction, and not be shocked? If she's going to ask questions like this, they may as well send Andy Rooney out on science stories.
Showing posts with label tv. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tv. Show all posts
Monday, January 11, 2010
Wednesday, August 05, 2009
SHARK WEEK: Not Just for the Discovery Channel Anymore
SHARK WEEK, which had 29 million viewers last year, is becoming some kind of international holiday. It's not just the Discovery Channel celebrating across the board with MythBusters' shark experiments and a reliving of Mike Rowe's shark Dirty Jobs. But now everyone's jumping on the SHARK WEEK bandwagon. Even the other networks.
Sharks Everywhere
Are You Smarter Than A Fifth Grader? (FOX) features a shark attack victim. Smithsonian Channel has a show on therapy for shark attack victims. The Early Show (CBS) is featuring a shark. My local PBS station had a show on a guy "with an unusual relationship with a shark." Showtime has a shark movie.
Win a Dream Date with a Shark Researcher!
The Shark Research Institute is auctioning off lunches with shark researchers around the globe, starting at $25--plus you pick up the tab for lunch. Chris "Air Jaws" Fallows is the hottie so far, but that's probably because he's throwing in a shark tour.
Dueling Petitions.
Think Shark Week is too sensational and bloody? Sign this petition of concerned scientists, surfers and other shark lovers.
Want more gore 24/7? Then this petition is for you.
Want Spain to stop finning sharks? Sign here.
European Shark Week
Just as you would expect from Europe, their Shark Week (Oct. 10-18, 2009) is short on melodrama and long on serious conservation. The Shark Alliance is asking Spain to stop chopping fins off live sharks and throwing the fish back to the ocean to bleed to death.
Sharks Everywhere
Are You Smarter Than A Fifth Grader? (FOX) features a shark attack victim. Smithsonian Channel has a show on therapy for shark attack victims. The Early Show (CBS) is featuring a shark. My local PBS station had a show on a guy "with an unusual relationship with a shark." Showtime has a shark movie.
Win a Dream Date with a Shark Researcher!
The Shark Research Institute is auctioning off lunches with shark researchers around the globe, starting at $25--plus you pick up the tab for lunch. Chris "Air Jaws" Fallows is the hottie so far, but that's probably because he's throwing in a shark tour.
Dueling Petitions.
Think Shark Week is too sensational and bloody? Sign this petition of concerned scientists, surfers and other shark lovers.
Want more gore 24/7? Then this petition is for you.
Want Spain to stop finning sharks? Sign here.
European Shark Week
Just as you would expect from Europe, their Shark Week (Oct. 10-18, 2009) is short on melodrama and long on serious conservation. The Shark Alliance is asking Spain to stop chopping fins off live sharks and throwing the fish back to the ocean to bleed to death.
Labels:
shark,
shark week,
tv
Monday, August 03, 2009
SHARK WEEK: What's More Dangerous than a Shark?
What could be more scary than a shark? Well, even during SHARK WEEK, pretty much anything.
Sharks kill about five people a year worldwide. The Global Shark Attack File chronicles 4,374 attacks since 1845. (They range from that first report, out of Sri Lanka, "Shark bit him in half, carrying away the lower extremities" to the trivial July 24 incident in Spain where some guy cut his foot.)
Sharks are sexier but not deadlier than:
Sharks kill about five people a year worldwide. The Global Shark Attack File chronicles 4,374 attacks since 1845. (They range from that first report, out of Sri Lanka, "Shark bit him in half, carrying away the lower extremities" to the trivial July 24 incident in Spain where some guy cut his foot.)
Sharks are sexier but not deadlier than:
- The water the shark is in is thousands of times more likely to kill you than the fish. In 2006 3,600 Americans drowned. Every year 260 toddlers drown in pools.
- Guns--just the accidental discharges--killed 642 in 2006, according to the CDC.
- 25 kids a year still suffocate in plastic bags, the Consumer Product Safety Commission says.
- Upholstered furniture takes out 460 Americans annually (because it catches on fire.)
- Extension cords kill 50 people a year in the United States (again, through fire.)
Labels:
shark,
shark attack,
shark week,
statistics,
tv
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)